Paul Scholes Tells Bruno Fernandes to ‘Just Go to Saudi’ After Criticism of Michael Carrick

Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has launched a strong criticism of club captain Bruno Fernandes, arguing that the midfielder can no longer be trusted to lead a team following his public comments about manager Michael Carrick.

Scholes described Fernandes’ remarks as “unforgivable” and suggested that the Portugal international should leave European football for Saudi Arabia.

The criticism follows a turbulent period at Old Trafford, with United struggling for results and questions growing over the relationship between players and the coaching staff.  

Paul Scholes Tells Bruno Fernandes to ‘Just Go to Saudi’ After Criticism of Michael Carrick

Scholes questions Fernandes’ leadership

Speaking on The Good, The Bad & The Football podcast, Scholes questioned whether Fernandes could continue to be trusted as captain after openly discussing Carrick’s tactical decisions.

“What Bruno Fernandes said last week, I think that’s unforgivable,” Scholes said, arguing that the comments could undermine the confidence managers and staff place in a captain.

He added that Fernandes should consider moving away from European football, saying he should “just go to Saudi”.

Scholes’ comments represent a sharp challenge to Fernandes’ standing at Manchester United, where the midfielder has been one of the club’s most influential players since arriving from Sporting Lisbon in 2020.

However, Scholes’ remarks are his personal assessment of the situation and do not mean the club has decided to remove Fernandes from the captaincy.

What Fernandes said about Carrick

The dispute began after Manchester United suffered a 4-1 Champions League defeat against Como on October 21.

Fernandes questioned the team’s approach to pressing, suggesting that United’s decision to sit back and allow Como time on the ball had helped the Italian side grow in confidence.

He argued that United sometimes needed to take greater risks by pressing higher and putting opponents under more pressure.

When asked whether Carrick had made a tactical mistake, Fernandes responded: “That’s on the manager and staff to see it, not me.”

Although the midfielder did not directly call for Carrick to be dismissed, his comments attracted criticism because they publicly highlighted disagreements over the team’s tactics.

Former players and pundits were divided over the situation, with some arguing that the captain should have handled the matter privately while others focused on the team’s poor performance.

Fernandes dropped for Bournemouth defeat

Carrick subsequently left Fernandes on the bench for Manchester United’s Premier League match against Bournemouth on October 25.

Fernandes remained an unused substitute as United suffered a 3-0 defeat at Old Trafford, adding to the pressure surrounding the club.

Carrick maintained that the selection decision was based on football considerations rather than disciplinary action.

The manager had previously acknowledged the importance of team dynamics and said his priority was doing what he believed was best for Manchester United.

The decision not to use Fernandes nevertheless intensified speculation about the relationship between the captain and his manager.

United have not publicly announced that Fernandes will be stripped of the captaincy, and Scholes’ comments should not be interpreted as confirmation of any formal club decision.

Nicky Butt also criticises Fernandes

Former Manchester United midfielder Nicky Butt, who appears alongside Scholes on the podcast, also criticised Fernandes’ handling of the situation.

Butt praised the midfielder’s commitment and previous contributions but argued that the interview had damaged the reputation he had built at Old Trafford.

He suggested Fernandes had previously shown a willingness to take responsibility for the club during difficult periods, making the public disagreement with Carrick particularly disappointing in his view.

The comments from both former players reflect growing frustration among some United supporters and club figures over the team’s performances and the public nature of the criticism directed at the coaching staff.

However, Fernandes remains an important figure at the club, and his longer-term position will depend on decisions made by Manchester United rather than comments from former players.

Fernandes’ contribution to Manchester United

Fernandes joined Manchester United from Sporting Lisbon in January 2020 and quickly became a key figure in the team’s attack.

He has regularly contributed goals, assists and creative opportunities, while taking on the captaincy and responsibility for leading the side during difficult periods.

His performances last season were particularly productive, but his output has declined during the current campaign, according to reporting by Goal and other football outlets.

That dip in form has added another dimension to the debate over his leadership, although criticism of his recent performances does not erase his previous contributions to the club.

The midfielder has also faced questions about his on-field reactions and communication with teammates, issues that have periodically attracted attention during his time in England.

What happens next for Fernandes and Carrick?

Manchester United’s immediate challenge is to improve their results and settle the uncertainty surrounding the relationship between the manager and senior players.

Carrick’s position has come under scrutiny following a series of disappointing performances, while Fernandes faces pressure to respond to criticism of his comments and his recent form.

United are scheduled to travel to Chelsea on Saturday, October 31, with the fixture providing another important test for the squad.

Whether Fernandes returns to the starting line-up remains a selection decision for Carrick. The club has not confirmed a change in captaincy, and there is no confirmed transfer agreement involving a move to Saudi Arabia.

For now, Scholes’ remarks have intensified the public debate over leadership at Old Trafford, but the most significant answers are likely to come from the team’s performances and the decisions made by the club’s management.

Previous Post Next Post

نموذج الاتصال